I connect to samba from XP or W2K, create file try to add ACE to the file's ACL After the submit the ACE disapear The smb.conf is workgroup = CIFS-DOMAIN wins server = 172.16.20.227 netbios name = aurora security = domain # security = ads realm = CIFS-DOMAIN.COM password server = * server string = CLLF load printers = no socket options = TCP_NODELAY local master = no domain master = no lock directory = /tmp name resolve order = wins host bcast dns proxy = yes winbind uid = 1-65535 winbind gid = 1-65535 idmap uid = 1-65535 idmap gid = 1-65535 log file = /var/tmp/samba_log.%m max log size = 100 log level = 10 syslog = 0 client use spnego = yes [cifs1] path = /export/cifs1 read only = No guest ok = Yes use sendfile = Yes
Created attachment 1800 [details] smbd old
Created attachment 1801 [details] smbd
Created attachment 1802 [details] winbind old
Created attachment 1803 [details] winbindd
Created attachment 1804 [details] client ip
Created attachment 1805 [details] client log
no bug can be seen here, looks more like configuration issue acutally. Please try with a modern, supported samba version and clean idmap configuration. If you then still see an issue consider to consult support and if it turns out to be a bug, then file a new report with steps for a compact reproducer.