Bug 1676 - %G / %g substitution variables do not work in Samba/Winbind
Summary: %G / %g substitution variables do not work in Samba/Winbind
Status: RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 2191
Alias: None
Product: Samba 3.0
Classification: Unclassified
Component: winbind (show other bugs)
Version: 3.0.6
Hardware: x86 Linux
: P3 major
Target Milestone: none
Assignee: Gerald (Jerry) Carter (dead mail address)
QA Contact: Samba QA Contact
Depends on:
Reported: 2004-08-28 09:35 UTC by Nayco (mail address dead)
Modified: 2005-02-17 10:03 UTC (History)
1 user (show)

See Also:


Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Nayco (mail address dead) 2004-08-28 09:35:58 UTC
When using %G or %g in an SMB.CONF directive, the substitution doesn't work.  
For exemple:  
# template homedir determines the home directory for winbind users, with  
# %D expanding to their domain name and %U expanding to their username:  
  template homedir = /home/%G/%U  
With this directive, when using "getent", we should get:  
$ getent passwd  
Here is what I actually get:  
The problem is that this bug seems to have been corrected by the Samba team in 
the 3.0.3 release of Samba, but is still present in Mandrake's 3.0.6 version. 
When compiling the source RPM, I saw that Mandrake patches the 3.0.6 tree  
with some older patches... I posted a bug report on Mandrake's bugzilla, and 
it was found that this issue seems Samba-related, not due to Mandrake. 
Well, is %g|G substitution really supposed to work in all the smb.conf 
directives, or is it restricted to a few ones ? (For exemple, NOT "template 
I'm using this feature on my production servers, and it worked till I upgraded 
to 3.0.2, then 3.0.6... Before that, I was using Samba 2.2.x (Mandrake before 
(Somebody said "Never upgrade prod servers...etc... !" I know, Iknow... :-/ )
Comment 1 Nayco (mail address dead) 2004-08-30 01:06:35 UTC
I tried to verify this by compiling both the official sources and Mandrake then 
RedHat's source RPMS, the bug is still present. 
[Well, I got a problem querying domain users with the official version of Samba 
(Compiled from "samba-latest.tar.gz"), winbind seem to be unable to find the 
domain controler... My mistake ? Well, this is another problem] 
To sum up, Samba 3.0.6 in major distros (Debian's behaves the same) has a %(g|
G) bug that prevents it's substitution when in some smb.conf directives. 
Comment 2 Gerald (Jerry) Carter (dead mail address) 2004-08-30 04:52:24 UTC
As I explained in the Mandrake report, winbindd cannot expand the %[gG]
variable.   Currently only, %[Uu], %D, and %N are supported for 'template 
homdir'. I'm looking into ways to expand the number of variables that 
could be supported winbind winbind parameters, but this is essentially
new functionality (i.e. it has never worked as far as I can tell).

If you know of a version where these variables did work in 'template 
homedir', please let me know.

Comment 3 Nayco (mail address dead) 2004-08-30 10:04:14 UTC
It worked with 2.2.7a.Mdk... Ok, here is what I do. 
My student are divided in two groups on the domain: "1stYear" and "2ndYear". 
So, on the fileserver, I got used to split the student's home directories based 
on their NT group name:  
This way, I find it cleaner, and I can provide 2 additionnal shares on my 
server: "1stYear" and "2ndYear", respectively /home/1stYear/ and /home/2ndYear. 
Ok, no matter why. I put this in my smb.conf: 
template homedir = /home/%G/%U 
...And the other usal directives. Join the domain, and when a student click on 
the share.... I DOES NOT WORK. 
I forgot: Samba tries to access "/home/DOMAIN\1stYear/student1 for exemple... 
Although I use the directive "winbind use default domain = yes": No effect 
here :-( ! 
I had to create symbolic links "/home/MyDomain\1stYear/" => "/home/1stYear/", 
and here we go. 
I've just tried on one of my servers (Still Mdk 9.1 : Samba 
2.2.7a-security-rollup-fix) : It DOES work. 
I intentionally tried by making "template homedir" to an inexistent directory, 
to se in the log how winbind makes the substitution : 
[2004/08/30 15:54:01, 0] smbd/service.c:make_connection(599) 
  xxx-xxx-pc-04 (172.xx.xx.185) Can't change directory 
to /home/toto/DOMAIN\1stYear/student1 (No such file or directory) 
But, when using "getent passwd", %g behaves erratically: 
Yes ! %g himself, but not subsitued... Still, that's better. 
Ok, now, let try with Samba 3.0.6Mdk: 
* Smb.conf : 
   winbind uid = 10000-20000 
   winbind gid = 10000-20000 
   ;  winbind separator = + 
   winbind use default domain = yes 
   template homedir = /home/%G/%U 
   ;  obey pam restrictions = yes 
   template shell = /bin/false 
* Getent passwd: 
* Connection to the "homes" share from a W2000 station: 
[2004/08/30 18:20:13, 2] smbd/service.c:make_connection(752) 
  [homes] share not available for this user because it was not found or created 
at session setup time 
   Sh** !  With 3.0.6, the path isn't shown anymore when not existing... Ok, 
let's create it ! 
[2004/08/30 18:45:30, 2] smbd/service.c:make_connection(752) 
  [homes] share not available for this user because it was not found or created 
at session setup time 
Ok, I'm tired. with older versions of Samba, it was more easily possible to 
know why we couldn't access a share... Path not found ? Bad unix permissions ? 
I had noticed that %(g|G) expanded to "DOMAIN\GROUP", which forced me to create 
folders like "/home/DOMAIN\GROUP/usernamexx". 
* Getent passwd 
  Mmmfff ! 
Well, I have three questions: 
- Is it possible to make Samba/Winbind more verbose about which folder is 
looked after when a user connects ? (I tried "debug level = 10", but it' 
looonnngggggg. I become readable with "4", but I cannot find what i'm looking 
for, except the above messages.) 
- Is it possible to have Winbindd expand correctly %(G|g) when connecting to a 
home directory (Like it did in 2.2.7 !) ? And, why not, also when using 
Getent ? 
- Is it possible to get it expanded without "DOMAIN\", like if using "winbind 
use default domain" ? It's more friendly sometimes ;-) 
Bonus question : If it worked in 2.2.7, why did it disappeared from 3.0.x ? 
Design decision, or I was lucky with 2.2.x ? 
Comment 4 Nayco (mail address dead) 2004-08-30 10:50:23 UTC
Ok, (semi-)good news : My last tests were done on a Samba 3.0.6 badly 
backported on a MDK10.0 form cooker, and I forgot to start again with an 
official MDK rpm (Which is now 3.0.2a). So, with Samba 3.0.2a: 
* Connection to the [Homes] share by "student1": 
[2004/08/30 19:29:50, 0] smbd/service.c:make_connection_snum(677) 
  '/home/10022/student1' does not exist or is not a directory, when connecting 
to [student1] 
Ok, so the problem comes truly visible here ! 
* getent passwd 
Hey, Look ! Above, "10022", and here, "10000" ??? 
NOTE: I alway had to set "1stYear" as the user's primary group, instead of 
"Domain users", so I have done here, Which explains the "10022". But the 
"10000" in Getent ? 
Comment 5 Gerald (Jerry) Carter (dead mail address) 2005-02-17 10:03:07 UTC

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 2191 ***