The Samba-Bugzilla – Bug 1384
File write and read access permision problems
Last modified: 2006-04-08 22:29:20 UTC
There is a problem with shares where any client cannot have write access. The
problem began sinces 3.0.3 (including 3.0.4) because with 3.0.2a, works
perfectly, even using the same configuration.
I have made some test, and I found that the problem is about the conflict
between the read only directive, write list and read list. The results of my
some tests that I did:
1) read only on, user in write list: Write access denied!
2) read only off, user in write list: Write access ok
3) read only off, user in read list and not in write list: Write access ok!
It seems that the read only directive is taken after procesing the write and
read list. That because, if the read only is off and user is in read list, the
user can write and the inverse is also true.
The tests was made using smbclient under linux 2.2 x86 and using a Windows XP
Please retest against a current release and reopen if the issue still exists.