From Rebecca Gellman rebecca at starfleet-net.co.uk:
I wish to tell you a tale of investigation and suspicion of a memory
leak in the ntlm_auth program (as compiled from
So in our system, we use ntlm_auth to provide both Kerberos and NTLM
authentication for transparent (and not-so transparent) web proxy
connections. In this particular instance, Kerberos is the auth of
choice, but I believe this is relevant to NTLM too.
We spawn up a pool of ntlm_auth processes on demand. If a process is not
available when a connection comes in, we create a new one up to a
The base software version is 4.2.10, as shipped with Debian 8 (Jessie).
Now that the particulars of the environment are out of the way.....
So we have a customer. And they phoned in a support call that their
system was falling over. We dive in remotely, and see each ntlm_auth
process is running at an impressive 1.7GB of memory in the "VIRT" column
of top. EEP!
Suspecting a memory leak, we compiled up version 4.2.10 with a call to
talloc_enable_leak_reporting_full() in source3/utils/ntlm_auth.c (why
isn't this a command line option at the least?), along with a mod to our
own processes to send CTRL+D to ntlm_auth prior to terminating the
process, and gathering the report on STDERR.
Left it running for a day and examined the report. Each process had on
average over 19,000 DATA_BLOBs of around 1.5K in size, reportedly
created at lib/util/base64.c line 35, the function
After digging through the code, this function is called on (pseudo-code)
&line_of_STDIN to decode the base64 blob input to a binary blob.
There's then a load of logic surrounding the 2-letter command code and
processing gensec, etc, etc, etc.
Now... the crux of the matter. If I compare with an earlier (3.x.x)
branch, we see that data_blob_free() is called on this returned blob
whenever the command handler returns. In 4.x.x this code has been
refactored, and the function manage_gensec_request() doesn't always call
data_blob_free(). In fact, it rarely calls it at all.
There's also a couple of returns that omit talloc_free(mem_ctx) that
seems to precede every other return in this function.
So, on this hunch, I added in the missing data_blob_free() calls and the
two talloc_free(mem_ctx) calls, and rebuilt. Now the same customer
system is sitting happily at a low memory usage, not showing so much of
a hint of a memory leak.
I've attached the patch we used to "correct" ntlm_auth.c. I'd be
interested to here some technical commentary from knowledge Samba bods
Rebecca Gellman (On behalf of SmoothWall)
this fix went to master with this commit:
Author: Stefan Metzmacher <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Date: Tue Apr 4 11:52:56 2017 +0200
That means this is fixed in 4.7 and later
Please make sure to close bugs when they are fixed and/or assign them to Karolin to include them in the release branches.